Friday, January 25, 2008

do ganas matter? and other questions

12jan08
do ganas matter?
Ganas: a spanish word for desire, energy or um-phf to do something. If you are without ganas you could be described as lazy - but other times it is just used to describe being worn-out.


I have had a lot of people ask me to teach them to speak English. To be completely honest I am not really interested in teaching English. It takes a lot of patience that I am not sure I have or am willing to put forward in that way. I tried to give Osvaldo an English lesson – or at least help him with his homework and I wore me out so much! And it frustrated me, tons! So that’s not good. I don’t want to do something (or start something) that makes me tired and angry. That sounds like a recipe for disaster! yuck. so what do I do? The issue of english classes has raised an interesting question for me:
Does it matter what I want to do? Does it matter if I am not interested in doing something? If Paraguayan want it and it is something that would help them – shouldn’t that be something that I want to do or just do! Does it matter if I like it? I don’t know how to draw the line. I don’t know how to balance whose needs/desires come first. I swore to serve Paraguayans – how do I balance Rachel things with what Paraguayans need? How selfish do I get to be when I am supposed to be being selfless?

question asking - i think is a good thing.

More questions and thoughts

Development:
don’t send money. don’t give anything away. don’t tell people they are going to receive x-amount of dollars because they are breathing. There is something to work-incentive. There is need, great need; Hungry people, kids without shoes, houses or educations, kids, moms and grandmas with parasites. How do you find the “poor line” where it is impossible to develop/move forward/improve your own life if you don’t have your basic needs met? How do you meet those basic needs without providing incentive for people to purposefully drop themselves below the line to receive the handouts? How do you light peoples fires about making their lives better? education? I don’t feel like most people want to learn. They say – yeah teach me. But they don’t say, yeah, I want to change the way I run my life – I am going stop burning my trash/littering, drinking alcohol when im pregnant, im going to start using condoms or I am going to be loyal to my partner. No one. In ningun pais, are people going to jump on the, “tell me and I am going to change my ways” bandwagon. So, I don’t know what I think that it’s a good idea that I am here saying…um…have you thought about ____?
Maybe I do know. I know that I like my city better when there isn’t trash everywhere. I know kids are healthier when they don’t have fetal alcohol syndrome. I know its better when people don’t have unwanted pregnancies. I knows its better when people are loyal to their partners. Why is this development? Why have I decided its my job to tell people? Who the hell gave me the knowledge and authority to go around telling other people how to live their lives?
Although maybe Im not here to boss people around.
I came to meet people. I came to learn languages. I came to share my life with people on the opposite side of the globe.
It still makes me feel awfully high and mighty. And I don’t have any right to.

4 comments:

Steve said...

Great questions, I've definitely asked myself some of the same. Helping people is hard work, and we're often asked to do things that we don't really see the value in. Good luck...I hope you figure out what's important and where to find balance.
Peace.

Unknown said...

My dear Rachel,
First off, question asking is a good thing :-) I've thought a lot about these things too as I contemplate being a PCV, and they are tough! But here are my thoughts for you (which can all be completed by "Easy for you to say. ;-)
Change is not easy, but you are suggesting good changes. Suggesting means people don't have to listen, which is hard. But when they do or when things finally happen, it's under their own steam, and that's great. Keep planting seeds, Rachel. You may not see them grow as quickly as you like (or at all; some may take more than 2 years) but you ARE doing wonderful things. I hope I can be like you someday, whether as a PCV or something else :-) I'm cheering for you! -Amy
P.S. I have been accepted to a grad program for Masters International and nominated, yay! Oh, and it's STILL frigid up here. Windchill of -22 in MKE today. I like winter and all, but ACK!!

Jfunk said...

hello dear. just a few thoughts on a few of your thoughts.

wanting to do good things and create positive change doesn't have to be a selfless act. please don't put your desires aside because those desires are what got you to where you are in the first place! you will only continue to do good work as long as you are motivated, dedicated, and happy (all three, not just one or two of them).

teaching isn't easy. there is nothing more frustrating than when your audience says "yes" but then turns around and ignores/forgets everything. but on the off chance that a few remember and change, we keep at it. "In teaching you cannot see the fruit of a day's work. It is invisible and remains so, maybe for twenty years." ~Jacques Barzun

tienes ganas de cambiar tu esquina del mundo y lo vas a hacer de tu manera! no te olvides que hay gente en tu vida que creen en lo que estas haciendo :)

besos, jess

Neal S said...

Like our discussion before of questioning - I love it its great. My question is do you feel challenged in what you are doing and do you think that the challenge of meeting the needs of what people ask you for is something that is realistic? What benefit to them will it be to learn English and in a way what will you gain from teaching them English.
Teaching might not be the right way to solve international projects. Being excited yourself and then having them join you in something seems to me to be a great way to get things done. Like more of a mentor than a teacher.
On an unrelated note Dr. Zitomer, EWB's adviser, told me on Friday to contact an MU Alum working in Africa to try and get established working with NGOs and such. Kind of a big change in course from working in Milwaukee but I'm going to explore it - keep exploring and have a great birthday!!